Average
on the mapThe default view. A GO's MWh displaces one MWh of the issuing country's average mix, so the multiple is the ratio of the two grids' intensity.
Emissions · European power grids
Carbon intensity of electricity generation, country by country — every complete year and the latest twelve months — from ENTSO-E and NESO data. Switch to CO₂ displaced and pick a base country to see how much more — or less — a Guarantee of Origin from anywhere else displaces.
Complete calendar years, plus the latest twelve complete months. Hatched: a covered country without complete data for the period; grey: outside the data this site serves. † Coverage gap. ENTSO-E misses a measured, material share of these countries' generation — plants on distribution grids (rooftop solar, small cogeneration and hydro), or output a TSO files as "other", which carries no emission factor here. Their Mt and TWh are lower bounds, and where the missing power is cleaner or dirtier than the rest, their intensity — and every GO multiple built on it — reads high or low: the country card says which, and by how much. See the methodology.
Each bubble is a country: how much power it generates (x, log scale), how dirty each kWh is (y), and how much CO2 that adds up to (bubble size). The top-right quadrant — big and dirty — is where new renewables cut the most tonnes. Follows the year selected on the map.
† coverage gap — Mt and TWh are lower bounds, and the intensity may read high or low; see the caveat under the map.
Methodology, drawn
A Guarantee of Origin certifies that one MWh of renewable electricity was produced. What that MWh avoided depends on where — and when — it was produced. Three ways to count it, and two things no index can tell you.
The default view. A GO's MWh displaces one MWh of the issuing country's average mix, so the multiple is the ratio of the two grids' intensity.
A grid's intensity moves through the day, and a solar MWh arrives with the sun. Weighting every hour by what solar — or wind — produced gives the grid that GO really met, and compares a solar GO with a solar GO.
In the short run an extra MWh does not replace the average mix: it pushes back the plant at the margin — usually gas or coal, often across a border. Multiples get much flatter. Doing it properly means finding that plant hour by hour from prices; it is on the roadmap.
How the multiple moves with the basis, for the largest markets.
These are lifecycle intensities, and renewable plants have a lifecycle footprint too. Netting it out barely moves a Polish GO but takes a large share off a Spanish or Norwegian one — so the index compares grids, gross.
The index says what an extra MWh would displace. A GO from a plant that runs anyway moves a claim, not a tonne of CO₂; only output your money causes — a PPA that gets a plant built — delivers what the map shows.
Monthly tonnes by fuel for any bidding zone — or pick a zone from a country on the map.
Stacked bars = monthly tCO2 by fuel. Intensity line = kgCO2 per MWh of total generation (the "how clean is this grid right now" number). Months are bucketed in the market's local timezone — DST shifts absorbed cleanly.
Side-by-side stacked bars for up to 4 bidding zones — the cleanest way to see which markets ran on coal and which ran on nuclear during the same months.
How fast the continent is decarbonising, and who is pulling ahead of — or falling behind — the pack.
The bold green line is the generation-weighted average across every covered ENTSO-E bidding zone — the EU plus the UK, Norway, Switzerland, and the Western Balkans. Grey traces are the individual countries — the spread shows how far the cleanest and dirtiest grids sit from the mean. Add up to seven markets — countries or bidding zones — to draw them in colour, here and in the Grid Carbon Index below, and download their series as CSV; the one selected on the map is drawn in white. Production-based, lifecycle factors; complete calendar years only.
Each country's intensity measured against the European average for that year — the generation-weighted mean of all covered ENTSO-E zones, EU and non-EU alike. Above 100 = dirtier than the typical European kWh; below 100 = cleaner. This strips out the "everyone decarbonised together" effect, so you can see who is actually pulling ahead of — or falling behind — the pack. The index moves if a country's intensity is flat while peers fall. Click a country below to add it to the comparison — the same markets as the chart above.
Every figure here is generation multiplied by a lifecycle emission factor for its production type (IPCC AR5 medians where AR5 has one), summed per country, bidding zone and period — production-based, complete periods only. Where a TSO's data misses part of a country, the figures carry a †.